A Fresh Look at Achievement Gaps: The Art of Asking Why | BookNook

Did you know? 98% of public schools reported that at least some students were behind grade level in math or reading in the 2024-2025 school year.

If you’re like most of us working in schools today, you’re probably asking some big questions about why certain gaps in learning just won’t close — even after years of new programs, new funding, and new strategies.

The truth is, there’s no quick fix. But asking better questions — and being willing to really look at the answers — can help us move forward in smarter ways.

Here’s where we can start.

1. Instructional Effectiveness: Are We Meeting Students Where They Are?

No two students learn exactly the same way. We know that. But in the middle of everything else—testing, staffing, new mandates—it’s easy to slip into "one size fits all" instruction and lose instructional depth in the process.

Questions to think about:

• Are we adjusting instruction enough to give every student a real shot at success?

• Why are certain strategies working for some kids, but not for others?

• Are we giving teachers the tools and time they need to support students with different starting points?

Learn More

2. Student Engagement: Are We Sparking Curiosity or Just Delivering Content?

Every leader knows: if students aren’t engaged, they aren’t learning. Full stop. And right now, too many kids are checking out — not because they don’t care, but because they don’t feel connected.

Questions to think about:

• Why are some students excited to learn, while others shut down?

• Are we making learning meaningful and accessible—or just getting through the lesson plan?

• How could small shifts in how we teach help students stay tuned in?

3. Support and Intervention: Are We Catching Students Before They Fall Behind?

Intervention can’t just be about scrambling after a student is already in trouble. It needs to be early, steady, and reachable — before small struggles turn into long-term gaps.

Questions to think about:

• Are we spotting students who need help early enough?

• Are the supports we offer actually reaching the kids who need them most?

• How are we making sure feedback is clear, supportive, and actionable for students?

4. Opportunity and Resources: Are We Creating Real Access to Learning?

We can’t ignore it: some students simply have more opportunities than others, even within the same district. That gap shows up in tutoring access, technology, enrichment programs—you name it.

Questions to think about:

• Are all our students getting strong learning opportunities, no matter what school they attend?

• Why do some groups consistently miss out on key supports?

• Are we putting resources where they can do the most good?

5. Accountability and Assessment: Are We Measuring What Matters?

Accountability is important — but if we’re only looking at test scores, we’re missing half the story. We need better ways to track real growth, not just snapshots.

Questions to think about:

• Are we using assessments to inform instruction—or just to sort students?

• Why aren’t we seeing more progress, even when we’re “checking the boxes”?

• How could we use the data we already have to ask better questions and make better decisions?

6. Funding and Priorities: Are We Putting Our Dollars Where They Matter Most?

Budgets are tight everywhere. But how we prioritize spending speaks volumes about what we value most—and whether we’re serious about closing gaps.

Questions to think about:

• Are we investing enough in early intervention and consistent support?

• Why do some schools or programs get stuck with fewer resources year after year?

• How could we shift funding (small scale and large scale) to make a bigger impact on student success?

7. Bigger Picture Factors: Are We Seeing the Whole Student?

We know learning doesn’t happen in a vacuum. Health, home life, stability, safety — they all shape how students show up to learn.

Questions to think about:

• How are broader factors like food security, mental health, and housing instability affecting our students?

• What partnerships or resources could help address these barriers?

• How can we build school environments where students feel ready to learn every day?

Every district is different. Every student is different. But the questions we ask — and the honesty with which we answer them — are what will define whether we make real progress.

When we stop chasing quick fixes and start building smarter supports, like targeted tutoring tied to real growth data, we give students a better shot at success.

BookNook’s High-Impact Tutoring program is just one piece of that puzzle. If you're ready to explore how targeted support can close gaps before they grow wider, we're here to help.